Coney Island Lunch Room Menu

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.

  • michael m.

    staff was nice but food was only ok . this well not be the best hotdog or hamburger you have ever had . it wasn't bad but deffinently not 5 stars . prices were cheap and service was fast . i'd eat there again .

    (3)
  • Momma M.

    Can't go wrong with the famous Coney Dog! YUM YUM YUM! And the homemade fries were great!

    (5)
  • Stephanie W.

    If you live I the area, or are just passing through, don't miss this terrific family owned establishment. We were in luck because 88 year old Gus (the 2nd generation owner) was there when we arrived, as was his son (3rd generation), who runs the place. When he heard we had come from N. J., Gus regaled us with stories of his time in the Army (1948 Ft. Dix, N. J.) and adventures in & around the N. Y. C. area. We then heard some very interesting, humorous stories about Grand Island. The gals who served us could not have been nicer & it really was like we were visiting. Oh yeah...THE FOOD....The Coney Dogs & Black and White malted were just great.

    (5)
  • Mark H.

    One of the best chili dogs I've ever had. My wife said it's the BEST she has ever had. A little hurtful since I've been making chili dogs for her for years. But - it's hard to disagree. A must stop if you are in the Grand Island area.

    (5)
  • Robert G.

    Coney dogs were pretty good. We have to eat GF and their French fries are GF! Closed at 3pm staff will take good care of you.

    (4)
  • Sandy C.

    This is the first place I want to go when I go back to my home town. I went there in grade school and high school ( long ago) and they still taste as delicious as ever! The best!!

    (5)
  • Albert L.

    I took a trip here on my way to Omaha and it was well worth the de-tour. It's slightly off the 80 and you must stop in! It definitely has an old school feel to it that you don't see around anymore. The owner greeted me and will tell you what he recommends - the hot dogs of course! I ordered 2 hot dogs with a side of fries. The real treat was the owner telling you stories and showing you pictures from back in the day. He has a real passion towards life and his business. The hot dogs were delicious as well. There are some places that you root for to do well, and this is one of them.

    (5)
  • Kaylea S.

    Coney Island is an iconic Grand Island eatery! How can it be anything less than 5 stars? Sure the food is greasy, sure its not the "cleanest" looking place to eat, sure the water glasses aren't crystal clear...this is exactly why I love coney island! They aren't trying to be anything they are not. This is a family place in every sense of the word. Its family owned and familes have been going here for generations. My heart belongs to Coney Island when I'm in GI. :)

    (5)
  • Rick P.

    The other day, I was reminiscing with a friend and recalled the very first job I ever had at the age of 12 through 13. It was at the Coney Island Café, working for Gus Katrouzos. This was in 1967-68. Gus was a truly great guy, and taught me a lot. He was quite a father figure to me and insisted I get my social security card (they weren't issued at birth then as they are now). Believe it or not I actually still have the original SS card that was issued to me back then. In the late 80's, while I was living and working in Denver, I passed through GI on the way to Omaha and stopped in to look up Gus. Surprisingly, he was still there. He didn't remember me, but we still had a great visit and talked about the good old days when I attended Walnut Jr. Hi School and worked several days a week at the Coney Island Café. By this time, though, I was old enough to stop in at the lounge next door ("something-a-go-go", as I recall) and have a cocktail after my 2 on 1 coney dog. Oddly enough, although I spent most of my adult life in law enforcement, I dabbled part-time in the restaurant and bar business, eventually owning, operating, and cooking in my own for nearly 6 years (while still working in law enforcement). Gus was somebody who made a huge impression on me, to the point that I have never forgotten him, nor his name.

    (5)
  • Michaela W.

    If you're looking for great fries, a coney dog, or a delicious malt this place is for you. I grew up in Grand Island, so I have many fond memories of eating here with my family as a kid. But it's my husband, an East Coast native, who really can't get enough of this place. When we visit my parents, he always me promise that we will visit Coney Island at least twice (though his preference would actually be every day). The food is always fantastic and the service is amazing. If you're going to eat lunch in Grand Island, you really should plan to stop here.

    (5)
  • Boyd D.

    Wow what a step back in time, best coney dawgs in the state!!! Great staff a must stop when you visit GI!!!

    (5)
  • Mark J.

    30's style Grand Island, Nebraska burger/dog joint. Just simply great. Must get a shake!

    (4)
  • Christie S.

    Okay, I read the reviews and decided I had to try it. I've gotta say, I don't get it. I don't get it at all. mediocre small hotdog on a bun with some sort of meat sauce and old raw onions. warm soda in a bottle. The milkshake my son had was pretty good. All in all I just don't get the draw of the place. My son and I shared an order of fries (soggy and greasy) he had a grilled cheese, me a coney dog, milkshake and soda and spent $15!! Frankly, I'd rather have a hotdog at the Sam's Club cafe anyday. I think maybe it's one of those places that brings back childhood memories or something but for me I just don't get it.

    (2)
  • Allie D.

    A visit to Coney Island is a step back in time! I have been visiting Coney every time I've been in GI since I was a little girl and it's the same every time. The restaurant itself is set up like an old school diner, with a row of booths and then a row of seats at the counter. The staff is so nice and welcoming, and they can always keep up with the lunch rush. The food is good, and cheap! I stick with the Coney dog, which is a hot dog with tasty meat sauce on top. The fries are the best - nice and crispy. There are old school machines making the milkshakes which are also a must. They are big enough to split! In a town with so many chain restaurants, it's refreshing to visit a unique family-run place. Whether you live in GI or are just visiting, you have to go to Coney Island!

    (4)
  • Rick J.

    Same fare for years makes the Coney an institution in GI and surrounding area. The only change I noticed after being away the last 45 years was the prices are much higher. Just a sign of the times. Just had two dogs, fries and coke for $10 with tip. Very tasty! Same location for years. Very small seating. Get there early or you will be waiting to get in!

    (4)
  • Sarah G.

    As the highest-rated restaurant in Grand Island, I had to make Coney my lunch stop on a recent work trip. The price ($15 for 2 people) was definitely right, and the coneys were amazing (as was the vanilla malt I indulged in on a whim). The fries were good too, but I'd recommend skipping in lieu of another dog. Plenty to look at while you're grabbing a quick bite up at the bar. This place obviously has a lot of history behind it and food that's stood the test of time.

    (4)
  • Julius C.

    I was again in Grand Island on business and heard about this place from a coworker. When you walk in, you instantly feel like you've stepped into a small town American institution. The place is narrow with a row of booths to the left and the long lunch counter to the right. Above the counter, you have a collection of miniature football helmets of NFL and college teams (funny enough they had my college team's helmet and even our rivals, those dang Cougars.). To the far left, they display the original 1933 menu where a cheese sandwich was more expensive than a burger and 35 cent t-bones. I also have to mention the old green Hamilton Beach milkshake maker right next to the newer grey one. You look around this busy lunch room and you know that the people who eat there are local regulars. My coworkers and I ordered the signature coney dog, a hot dog with a meat chili topping, mustard, and onions. We also had fries and milkshakes. To be honest, the coney dogs were just ok, the fries weren't bad, but the milkshakes were just awesome. I would go back just for those milkshakes. Bottomline, this place has a lot of history, charm, and local flavor. Stop by for lunch (before 3 pm) and try a milkshake.

    (4)
  • Jodi A.

    Lived in G.I. for years! Graduated from Senior! Going back for my 30 year class reunion! So excited to go to Coney Island!

    (5)
  • Alon W.

    Don't ask me why, but my in-laws choose to live in Grand Island, Nebraska. We don't visit frequently, but Coney Island makes it worth the six-hour trip. It's wonderful.

    (5)
  • Sammy F.

    My dad is from Grand Island so every year we visit, it is mandatory to stop and get some coneys and malts. We have nothing like it back home. The customer service is also spectacular. I included a picture of the original menu from 1933 when it opened. Yesterday, we had what is probably our last time eating at Coney Island (because grandma recently passed away), so we had a toast to the grandparents with our last coneys. It's a bittersweet moment leaving something that has been a longstanding part our lives. I hope another family takes up this fabulous place as their lunch spot like mine did.

    (5)
  • Mike S.

    Just some tips for other rookies: 1- seat yourself 2- use a spoon to pour your shake into the glass 3- the hamburgers are just as good as the dogs 4- don't wait for a bill/ticket, just head to the register and tell them what you had will be back

    (4)
  • Last L.

    Yeah it's a pretty good coney. Go for the service in late afternoon when no one is there, and sit around listening to Gus tell you stories about the old days. He'll talk your ear off. The fries are great as well. Unbelievably low cost. Think i paid $5 for a coney, fries and a beve.

    (4)
  • Dave F.

    Absolutely the best coney (chili) dogs you will ever have. Sauce mustard and onions, don't even THINK of asking for ketchup (except for wonderful home-made fries). And it's true, Gus and his son George will remember you even if you (like me) hadn't lived in GI or been to Coney Island in years. Truly a Class lunchroom, if there is such a thing

    (5)
  • Peter P.

    This place haunts my dreams. I grew up eating the coney dog's at Gus's diner. They are magnificent. If his kids run it as he did, then it is still magnificent. The chili is homemade, with meat ground so fine it's almost like powder. The buns are steamy and squishy. Every coney dog is topped with chili, onion and mustard - that's it. Fresh homemade fries on the side. I haven't been to GI in about 15 years, but I would make special trip just to have a couple of coney dogs.

    (5)
  • John M.

    Coney dogs - delicious! This place is old school and charming. I even bought a t-shirt last time I was there! It's a short drive off the highway but well worth it on the long trip across the midwest.

    (5)
  • Jason W.

    You must experience this place if you are ever in G.I. A definite Grand Island delicacy. You must try the chili, coney dog w/ onions and fries. You will leave satisfied....and you can still taste it later that night too!

    (5)
  • Mark H.

    One of the best chili dogs I've ever had. My wife said it's the BEST she has ever had. A little hurtful since I've been making chili dogs for her for years. But - it's hard to disagree. A must stop if you are in the Grand Island area.

    (5)
  • Rick J.

    Same fare for years makes the Coney an institution in GI and surrounding area. The only change I noticed after being away the last 45 years was the prices are much higher. Just a sign of the times. Just had two dogs, fries and coke for $10 with tip. Very tasty! Same location for years. Very small seating. Get there early or you will be waiting to get in!

    (4)
  • Sarah G.

    As the highest-rated restaurant in Grand Island, I had to make Coney my lunch stop on a recent work trip. The price ($15 for 2 people) was definitely right, and the coneys were amazing (as was the vanilla malt I indulged in on a whim). The fries were good too, but I'd recommend skipping in lieu of another dog. Plenty to look at while you're grabbing a quick bite up at the bar. This place obviously has a lot of history behind it and food that's stood the test of time.

    (4)
  • Robert G.

    Coney dogs were pretty good. We have to eat GF and their French fries are GF! Closed at 3pm staff will take good care of you.

    (4)
  • Sandy C.

    This is the first place I want to go when I go back to my home town. I went there in grade school and high school ( long ago) and they still taste as delicious as ever! The best!!

    (5)
  • Albert L.

    I took a trip here on my way to Omaha and it was well worth the de-tour. It's slightly off the 80 and you must stop in! It definitely has an old school feel to it that you don't see around anymore. The owner greeted me and will tell you what he recommends - the hot dogs of course! I ordered 2 hot dogs with a side of fries. The real treat was the owner telling you stories and showing you pictures from back in the day. He has a real passion towards life and his business. The hot dogs were delicious as well. There are some places that you root for to do well, and this is one of them.

    (5)
  • Kaylea S.

    Coney Island is an iconic Grand Island eatery! How can it be anything less than 5 stars? Sure the food is greasy, sure its not the "cleanest" looking place to eat, sure the water glasses aren't crystal clear...this is exactly why I love coney island! They aren't trying to be anything they are not. This is a family place in every sense of the word. Its family owned and familes have been going here for generations. My heart belongs to Coney Island when I'm in GI. :)

    (5)
  • Last L.

    Yeah it's a pretty good coney. Go for the service in late afternoon when no one is there, and sit around listening to Gus tell you stories about the old days. He'll talk your ear off. The fries are great as well. Unbelievably low cost. Think i paid $5 for a coney, fries and a beve.

    (4)
  • michael m.

    staff was nice but food was only ok . this well not be the best hotdog or hamburger you have ever had . it wasn't bad but deffinently not 5 stars . prices were cheap and service was fast . i'd eat there again .

    (3)
  • Momma M.

    Can't go wrong with the famous Coney Dog! YUM YUM YUM! And the homemade fries were great!

    (5)
  • Stephanie W.

    If you live I the area, or are just passing through, don't miss this terrific family owned establishment. We were in luck because 88 year old Gus (the 2nd generation owner) was there when we arrived, as was his son (3rd generation), who runs the place. When he heard we had come from N. J., Gus regaled us with stories of his time in the Army (1948 Ft. Dix, N. J.) and adventures in & around the N. Y. C. area. We then heard some very interesting, humorous stories about Grand Island. The gals who served us could not have been nicer & it really was like we were visiting. Oh yeah...THE FOOD....The Coney Dogs & Black and White malted were just great.

    (5)
  • Rick P.

    The other day, I was reminiscing with a friend and recalled the very first job I ever had at the age of 12 through 13. It was at the Coney Island Café, working for Gus Katrouzos. This was in 1967-68. Gus was a truly great guy, and taught me a lot. He was quite a father figure to me and insisted I get my social security card (they weren't issued at birth then as they are now). Believe it or not I actually still have the original SS card that was issued to me back then. In the late 80's, while I was living and working in Denver, I passed through GI on the way to Omaha and stopped in to look up Gus. Surprisingly, he was still there. He didn't remember me, but we still had a great visit and talked about the good old days when I attended Walnut Jr. Hi School and worked several days a week at the Coney Island Café. By this time, though, I was old enough to stop in at the lounge next door ("something-a-go-go", as I recall) and have a cocktail after my 2 on 1 coney dog. Oddly enough, although I spent most of my adult life in law enforcement, I dabbled part-time in the restaurant and bar business, eventually owning, operating, and cooking in my own for nearly 6 years (while still working in law enforcement). Gus was somebody who made a huge impression on me, to the point that I have never forgotten him, nor his name.

    (5)
  • Michaela W.

    If you're looking for great fries, a coney dog, or a delicious malt this place is for you. I grew up in Grand Island, so I have many fond memories of eating here with my family as a kid. But it's my husband, an East Coast native, who really can't get enough of this place. When we visit my parents, he always me promise that we will visit Coney Island at least twice (though his preference would actually be every day). The food is always fantastic and the service is amazing. If you're going to eat lunch in Grand Island, you really should plan to stop here.

    (5)
  • Boyd D.

    Wow what a step back in time, best coney dawgs in the state!!! Great staff a must stop when you visit GI!!!

    (5)
  • Mark J.

    30's style Grand Island, Nebraska burger/dog joint. Just simply great. Must get a shake!

    (4)
  • Christie S.

    Okay, I read the reviews and decided I had to try it. I've gotta say, I don't get it. I don't get it at all. mediocre small hotdog on a bun with some sort of meat sauce and old raw onions. warm soda in a bottle. The milkshake my son had was pretty good. All in all I just don't get the draw of the place. My son and I shared an order of fries (soggy and greasy) he had a grilled cheese, me a coney dog, milkshake and soda and spent $15!! Frankly, I'd rather have a hotdog at the Sam's Club cafe anyday. I think maybe it's one of those places that brings back childhood memories or something but for me I just don't get it.

    (2)
  • Sammy F.

    My dad is from Grand Island so every year we visit, it is mandatory to stop and get some coneys and malts. We have nothing like it back home. The customer service is also spectacular. I included a picture of the original menu from 1933 when it opened. Yesterday, we had what is probably our last time eating at Coney Island (because grandma recently passed away), so we had a toast to the grandparents with our last coneys. It's a bittersweet moment leaving something that has been a longstanding part our lives. I hope another family takes up this fabulous place as their lunch spot like mine did.

    (5)
  • Mike S.

    Just some tips for other rookies: 1- seat yourself 2- use a spoon to pour your shake into the glass 3- the hamburgers are just as good as the dogs 4- don't wait for a bill/ticket, just head to the register and tell them what you had will be back

    (4)
  • Allie D.

    A visit to Coney Island is a step back in time! I have been visiting Coney every time I've been in GI since I was a little girl and it's the same every time. The restaurant itself is set up like an old school diner, with a row of booths and then a row of seats at the counter. The staff is so nice and welcoming, and they can always keep up with the lunch rush. The food is good, and cheap! I stick with the Coney dog, which is a hot dog with tasty meat sauce on top. The fries are the best - nice and crispy. There are old school machines making the milkshakes which are also a must. They are big enough to split! In a town with so many chain restaurants, it's refreshing to visit a unique family-run place. Whether you live in GI or are just visiting, you have to go to Coney Island!

    (4)
  • Julius C.

    I was again in Grand Island on business and heard about this place from a coworker. When you walk in, you instantly feel like you've stepped into a small town American institution. The place is narrow with a row of booths to the left and the long lunch counter to the right. Above the counter, you have a collection of miniature football helmets of NFL and college teams (funny enough they had my college team's helmet and even our rivals, those dang Cougars.). To the far left, they display the original 1933 menu where a cheese sandwich was more expensive than a burger and 35 cent t-bones. I also have to mention the old green Hamilton Beach milkshake maker right next to the newer grey one. You look around this busy lunch room and you know that the people who eat there are local regulars. My coworkers and I ordered the signature coney dog, a hot dog with a meat chili topping, mustard, and onions. We also had fries and milkshakes. To be honest, the coney dogs were just ok, the fries weren't bad, but the milkshakes were just awesome. I would go back just for those milkshakes. Bottomline, this place has a lot of history, charm, and local flavor. Stop by for lunch (before 3 pm) and try a milkshake.

    (4)
  • Jodi A.

    Lived in G.I. for years! Graduated from Senior! Going back for my 30 year class reunion! So excited to go to Coney Island!

    (5)
  • Alon W.

    Don't ask me why, but my in-laws choose to live in Grand Island, Nebraska. We don't visit frequently, but Coney Island makes it worth the six-hour trip. It's wonderful.

    (5)
  • Dave F.

    Absolutely the best coney (chili) dogs you will ever have. Sauce mustard and onions, don't even THINK of asking for ketchup (except for wonderful home-made fries). And it's true, Gus and his son George will remember you even if you (like me) hadn't lived in GI or been to Coney Island in years. Truly a Class lunchroom, if there is such a thing

    (5)
  • Peter P.

    This place haunts my dreams. I grew up eating the coney dog's at Gus's diner. They are magnificent. If his kids run it as he did, then it is still magnificent. The chili is homemade, with meat ground so fine it's almost like powder. The buns are steamy and squishy. Every coney dog is topped with chili, onion and mustard - that's it. Fresh homemade fries on the side. I haven't been to GI in about 15 years, but I would make special trip just to have a couple of coney dogs.

    (5)
  • John M.

    Coney dogs - delicious! This place is old school and charming. I even bought a t-shirt last time I was there! It's a short drive off the highway but well worth it on the long trip across the midwest.

    (5)
  • Jason W.

    You must experience this place if you are ever in G.I. A definite Grand Island delicacy. You must try the chili, coney dog w/ onions and fries. You will leave satisfied....and you can still taste it later that night too!

    (5)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Map

Opening Hours

  • Mon :8:30 am - 5:00pm

Specialities

  • Takes Reservations : No
    Delivery : No
    Take-out : Yes
    Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
    Good For : Lunch
    Parking : Street
    Bike Parking : Yes
    Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
    Good for Kids : Yes
    Good for Groups : Yes
    Attire : Casual
    Ambience : Casual
    Noise Level : Average
    Alcohol : No
    Outdoor Seating : No
    Has TV : No
    Waiter Service : Yes
    Drive-Thru : No

Categories

Burgers

Burger or Hamburger is savored as the most desired fast food meal in the United States. A hamburger is basically a sandwich prepared by stuffing ground meat patty, generally beef, between two slices of a bun cut in half. Hamburger is also famous for its seasoning. Most popular condiments used in hamburgers in the United States are mustard, mayonnaise, and ketchup. Besides ground meat patty, hamburgers are also stuffed with lettuce, onions, tomato slices, pickles, and cheese.

Hamburgers are also categorized into two types in the United States. Fast food hamburger and individual hamburgers served at restaurants are two basic types of burgers served in the United States. The individual hamburgers served at restaurants are prepared using everything including lettuce, onion, tomato, and sliced pickles as well as melted cheese on the patty or crumbled on top. American restaurants also serve veggie burgers for those who don't relish meat. Cheeseburgers are also hot favorite in the United States.

McDonalds is the most popular fast food burger restaurant serving different types of burgers in the United States. On the other hand, there are several restaurants such as Burger King are famous for serving the best hamburgers in the United States. Most burger restaurants in the United States often serve hamburgers with French fries and other condiments. If you have a liking for burgers in the United States, then you won't be disappointed. You can easily find the best burger restaurants in your city on our Restaurants Listings directory. Check the reviews and ratings of the top burger restaurants and savor yourself with the best hamburger in the city.

Coney Island Lunch Room

Share with your social network

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

© 2024 Restaurant Listings. All rights reserved.